Should every child be tagged and tracked?
CURRICULUM: Responsibility to Others: People Like You & Me
Summary: For more than 10,000 years, adults have cared for their children, and other people's children. Sometimes, children wander off, and sometimes, bad things happen. Modern technology allows adults to tag and track their children, to monitor their location, send and receive messages, even maintain history of their children's activities. Is this responsible parenting, or overprotection? Is the “creepy factor” significant? Or is this just a clever entrepreneurial scheme?
Basic Understanding:
-
Do children enjoy rights of privacy? (in U.S., and elsewhere)
-
Statistics: how many children are lost, abducted each year? Trending up or down?
-
Child development: how children's personal safety evolves as they grow up.
-
History of tagging people (including prisoners), pets, seniors, young children
Issues:
-
Public safety benefits, personal safety benefits
What is the new normal?
Distinction between public/personal safety and spying?
"You can't run, you can't hide" - how much freedom is enough freedom?
-
What is the job of a contemporary parent and contemporary community?
Children, freedom, neighborhood responsibility, "popsicle test"
Parent’s responsibility: keep an eye on your children at all times
Distracted parenting - do we "look away" more often than before?
-
Embedding digital devices into human bodies - medical, safety, psychological considerations
-
Cultural and political situation in other nations; International and cross-border issues
Open Questions:
-
"Your permanent record" - tracking, collecting, storing a lifetime of movement and activity
-
"Everybody must get chipped" - chip seniors, at-risk youth, babies, felons past and present, etc.
-
Data collection, storage, analysis, ownership (short- and long-term)
Combining tracking data with other (consumer, medical, etc.) data; profiling
-
Should tracking be a public (government, nonprofit) public service, or a business opportunity?
Conversation Pit: Possible Topics
-
Features you may enjoy on your embedded chip
-
Digital technology future
-
Law enforcement future
-
Legal and personal rights issues
Notebook Contents
-
Federal and State law, international law
-
Privacy in the United States
-
Fourth Amendment Rights (Search and seizure; Supreme Court Cases)
-
Privacy Rights in various nations (UK, China, Saudi Arabia)
-
Technologies used for personal surveillance (RFID, NFC, etc.)
-
Child psychology: Children’s need for privacy at different ages
-
Tagging pets, seniors, felons; benefits to alzheimer’s patients, special needs
Examples of Web Assets
-
The First VeriChip Implant Family[1]
-
Big Brother? School District Tracks Students with RFID Implant[2]
-
VeriChip’s Merger with Credit Monitoring Firm Worries Privacy Activists[3]
-
Fox News discusses implanting seniors with microchips[4]
-
Audio Excerpt of “The Circle” by Dave Eggers[5]
-
Forbes Video of RFID Implant[6]
Scholars, Books, Other Sources
-
Technology/Legal Scholar: future of personal security, privacy
-
Parents' organization: protection of children
-
Technologist: what is possible
-
Public policy scholars, lawmakers
-
Medical / psychologist experts
Creative / Educational Opportunities
-
Song parody: “Every Breath You Take (I'll Be Watching You")
-
Interactive mapping game based upon iPhone Find Friends
-
ADD MORE
[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hM2zWVP5HEg
[2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fknkC8US_dU
[3] http://www.wired.com/2009/12/positive_id/
[4] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MAI2-_hnFH0
[5] http://www.openculture.com/2013/09/free-audio-a-taste-of-dave-eggers-new-novel.html